Mortgage

Should I Pay Off My Mortgage or Invest?

This question comes up constantly, and the internet is full of oversimplified takes in both directions. Always invest because the math wins. Or pay off the mortgage first because debt is dangerous. Neither extreme is right for most Canadians.

The Math

The comparison is straightforward. What is your after-tax mortgage rate versus your expected after-tax investment return?

Your mortgage rate is already an after-tax cost when you are paying it with personal after-tax dollars, which most Canadians do. In the current environment, a typical Canadian mortgage renewing might be in the range of 4.5 to 5.5 percent.

Your expected investment return depends on your portfolio. A globally diversified equity portfolio has returned roughly 7 to 10 percent annually over long periods before inflation, and 5 to 7 percent after inflation. But that is before tax. In a TFSA, it is tax-free. In an RRSP, it is tax-deferred. In a non-registered account, dividends and capital gains are taxed annually.

The rough answer is this. If your mortgage rate is 5 percent and your expected after-tax investment return in a TFSA is 7 percent, investing wins mathematically. If your mortgage rate is 6 percent and you are investing in a taxable account at the same 7 percent, it is much closer, and the guarantee of paying off debt starts to look attractive.

The Tax Angle for Incorporated Professionals

If you are incorporated, the comparison changes in your favour. You can pay your mortgage using corporate dividends, which are taxed at a lower personal rate than salary, effectively reducing the after-tax cost of servicing the debt. If your corporation is investing at a good return, the retained earnings growing inside the corporation may be outpacing the mortgage rate, especially if you are not drawing the cash out personally anyway.

The Smith Manoeuvre is also worth understanding. It is a strategy where you use a Home Equity Line of Credit to borrow and invest in income-producing assets, making the interest tax-deductible. For the right person with the right temperament and financial position, this can be powerful. It adds leverage and complexity, so it is not for everyone, but it is a legitimate planning tool.

The Human Answer

The math is only part of it. The psychological value of owning your home outright is real and should not be dismissed.

For some people, mortgage debt creates ongoing anxiety that affects decision-making and quality of life. Eliminating it provides a form of financial security that no investment return can replicate. If that is you, there is nothing wrong with prioritizing the mortgage.

For others, the thought of money sitting in equity instead of compounding in the market is what creates anxiety. Those people should invest.

The best financial plan is one you will actually stick to.

The Practical Framework

Here is how I think about this decision with clients. First, max your TFSA if it is not already maxed. Tax-free compounding is hard to beat and should come before accelerating mortgage payments. Second, contribute to your RRSP if applicable. The tax deduction today and tax-deferred growth usually beats a guaranteed 5 percent mortgage paydown. Third, if you have any high-interest debt elsewhere, pay that first, always. Fourth, after registered accounts are handled, compare your mortgage rate to your expected non-registered return after tax. If investing wins by more than 1 to 2 percent, invest. If it is close, split the difference. Fifth, if you are within 5 years of retirement, the calculus shifts. Entering retirement debt-free reduces income pressure and is generally worth prioritizing.

The Answer Some People Like, and Most Might Not

Considering that mortgage debt is some of the cheapest you can buy, the most financially optimal answer is almost always to max your registered accounts first, then split extra cash between mortgage acceleration and investing. It’s not a satisfying answer because it is not all-or-nothing. But if historical averages hold, investing in a tax-efficient way can provide returns that have historically outpaced mortgages.

Want to model this for your specific situation, including your corporate assets? Email me directly at harry.sale@raymondjames.ca or book a meeting with me at https://calendly.com/harry-sale

Harry Sale is a Financial Advisor in Toronto specializing in evidence-based wealth management for incorporated professionals, business owners, physicians, dentists, lawyers and executives. He holds the CIM and QAFP designations

Tag Cloud